WhereYouEat's List of Best Pizza in South Shore Staten Island – Top 10 Local Favorites 

This list is not in any particular order - it is based on the TOP 10 MOST VIEWED Listings!  If you are searching for the best pizza in South Shore Staten Island, the stretch from Eltingville down to Tottenville has some of the most popular pizzerias on the island. From classic slices to upside-down Sicilian and Chicago-style pan pies, these are real local spots that South Shore residents actually order from all the time.

This guide features ten unique pizza spots on the South Shore of Staten Island, listed in no particular order. Each one links to its full profile on WhereYouEat.com so you can view menus, photos and more before you decide where to order from.

Frank & Danny’s – Eltingville / Great Kills Border

Frank & Danny’s on Amboy Road is a true South Shore staple. It sits right in the Eltingville / Great Kills area and is known for classic Staten Island style pizza: crisp but foldable crust, balanced sauce and cheese, and dependable slices all day long.

Best for: classic neighborhood pies, Sicilian pizza and reliable delivery in the Eltingville and Great Kills area.

The Original Giuseppe’s Pizza – Eltingville

The Original Giuseppe’s Pizza is another Amboy Road landmark in Eltingville. This pizzeria feels like it has always been part of the neighborhood. They offer regular and Sicilian pies, stuffed pies, rolls and a full Italian takeout menu.

Best for: old school Staten Island pizzeria atmosphere, hearty slices and ordering for a big family or group in Eltingville.

Casa Nino’s – Arden Heights

Casa Nino’s is located in Arden Heights off Arthur Kill Road and balances a full Italian restaurant experience with solid pizza. It is a popular choice when you want a sit-down dinner, parties, or takeout that includes both pies and pasta dishes.

Best for: pizza plus full Italian dinners in, a slightly more “night out” feel and family gatherings. Monday's Parm Hero Nights

Ambrosino’s Arden Ave – Arden Heights

Ambrosino’s on Arden Ave sits in the Arden Heights neighborhood and is known for its pan pies and specialty toppings. Locals talk about their pan pizza and creative combinations that work perfectly when you are feeding a table of friends or family.

Ambrosino’s Pizzeria is proud to have been featured on Impractical Jokers, a highlight still celebrated — fans can even order the famous “Q Pie,” named after Brian "Q" Quinn

Best for: pan pies, heavier specialty pizzas and family-style orders in the Arden Heights area of South Shore Staten Island.

Pizzaioli – Eltingville / Great Kills

Pizzaioli on Arthur Kill Road is in the Eltingville / Great Kills zone and has become a favorite for people who like variety. The counter is usually loaded with different slice options such as upside-down Sicilian, buffalo chicken, chicken Caesar and more, plus a dining room and frequent specials.

Best for: creative slices, upside-down Sicilian and sit-down dining with entrée deals in the Eltingville / Great Kills area.

Big Al’s – Great Kills

Big Al’s on Hylan Boulevard in Great Kills is famous for its Chicago-style pan pizza and breadcrumb-topped pies. Many locals grew up on Big Al’s and still consider it one of the must-visit spots for something different from the standard New York slice.

They've recently became famous for their Complete Family dinner which includes 3 1/2 Trays with Garlic Bread & Soda for $35!

Best for: Chicago-style pan pies, breadcrumb pizza and classic Great Kills pizzeria nostalgia.

Mamma Mia Pizzeria & Cucina – Rossville

Mamma Mia Pizzeria & Cucina in Rossville is another strong neighborhood option. It is often mentioned as one of the best pizzas in that part of the South Shore. Customers come for both the pies and the full Italian menu, including heroes and entrées.

Best for: dependable neighborhood pizza in Rossville, hero sandwiches and Italian dishes for delivery or takeout.

The Square on Annadale – Eltingville / Annadale

The Square on Annadale sits in the Eltingville / Annadale area and focuses on square pies. It is a go-to spot for thick Sicilian, upside-down pizzas and specialty squares. If you are craving a square slice on the South Shore, this is one of the first places many locals think of.

Best for: Sicilian pies, upside-down squares and sharing a tray of pizza with friends or family in Annadale and Eltingville.

Palermo Pizzeria Restaurant – Tottenville

Palermo Pizzeria Restaurant is located in Tottenville at the bottom of South Shore Staten Island. It operates as a full restaurant with a strong pizza menu. Families use Palermo for birthday dinners, after-game meals and large party trays.

Best for: sit-down Italian dinners, classic pies and party trays in Tottenville.

Towne Deli – Tottenville

Towne Deli on Arthur Kill Road in Tottenville is a landmark that combines deli food, hot heroes and pizza. Even though many people think of it first for sandwiches, the pizza is a big reason why it stays on the regular rotation for locals.

Best for: a mix of pizza, heroes and comfort food at the southern end of South Shore Staten Island.

They are also well known for their Daily 1/2 Tray Specials

Honorable Mentions on the South Shore

Beyond this Top 10 list of the best pizza in South Shore Staten Island, there are several other pizzerias that regulars search for on WhereYouEat: Ciro’s for thin crust pizza, Il Forno for Sicilian style pies, Mona Lisa for a well-rounded Italian menu, and Gigi & Keke for upside-down square pizza.

However you like your slice – thin, Sicilian, pan or upside-down – the South Shore of Staten Island has something that fits. Use this guide as a starting point, then explore more pizzerias, menus and photos directly on WhereYouEat.com by searching for “best pizza South Shore Staten Island” or browsing by neighborhood.