Marianne Wagner

"Love the Pizza! BEST Vodka sauce around!!"

"January 16, 2020"

sarah

"I would give this place zero stars if I could. When this place operated as Al's pizza with the former owners it was much better. I thought I would give the new "Justino's" a try and the pizza was terrible. It seems like they are just interested in money and ripping people off. I'd rather get a frozen pizza from the supermarket!"

"January 16, 2020"

jake

"U people posting are obviously clueless......Justinos pizza on jewett is the best pizza i ever had in all of ny....nevermind just S.I.....thier square pies are unbelievableand the place was completely renovated...when i hear all these bad reviews i know its got to be comming from thier competitors.they have the best pie in staten island...and who cares if an italian and a egyptian ownsthe place ..isnt this america! This has been a nieghborhood place for 50 years -i hope they are therefor another 50......peace"

"January 16, 2020"

Keepthemoneyinthiscountry

"This place is great, they will be opened on New Years EvE until 2AM, HIGHlY doubt the owners will be there though, they will let the poor kids work and ruin there NYE celebration, well thats what happens when a Italian goes into Business with a Arab I say go to a pizza place where the money will stay in the country and not get sent oversees"

"January 16, 2020"

nypdjen

"I've ordered various things from this restaurant and the only thing I like is the baked ziti. The pizza sucks, the linguini with clam sauce had no taste at all. The presentation was nice, it "looked" like it would taste good but had no flavor at all. The garlic bread wasnt great either. And every time I call to order something to be picked up, it always takes a lot longer than what they say. Needless to say I order my pizza elsewhere."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"The food is ok....but what really irked me was that i was charged $1 for a small cup of sauce.....rip off>> if you ask for parmesan on the side, be prepared for a dirty look....and they will give you a teaspoon amount...."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"This was the worst pizza I've ever had in my life. DO NOT GO THERE."

"January 16, 2020"

womanvsfood

"Had an urge for wings and ordered from justinos since it's down the block. I don't usually love wings from pizzerias with the exception of deninos and this place has great wings!!! I wanted to call and place another order. The people were nice too and really quick service. They even called to let me know my order was ready."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"they called to let you know your food was ready, because they wanted to know if it was a prank or not, and it was fast cause the place isnt busy"

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"wouldnt get caught up with the health dept, i know many places have been shut down for inconsequential stuff. for example; if your faucet dont reach all compartments of your sink its 30 points... so dont be persuaded by letter grades or places being shut down. i know many places that should be shut down and arent and vice versa. the old al's operated for years filthy dirty mess, justinos took over and spent a ton of money and were shut down for nonsence. i know them personally and if anyone has any questions they will give you a complete tour, like they did for me. place is super clean!!!!! they deserve a fair shot."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"that last post was pretty funny, but i wouldnt take it too seriousley,been too justinos on jewett 5 or 6 times the place is immaculate as well as the staff, from what i could see anyway, compared too what that place used too look like its the taj mahal!!! and as far as the disposition of the people who work there ive always been treated with the utmost respect and proffesionalism. i dont know the owners personally but i heard they kept the sign they found outside out of respect for the old establishment that has been a neighborhhod staple for 50 years.. i commend them for that. i can only tell you the experience i had and it was very good!!! try it you wont be disapointed."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"I passed by this place Wednesday Night around 9 pm and it was closed, I seena sign on the door and it said the health dept has shut it down, upon further review I check online to see what it was shut down for but couldnt find it, I did find out that it was shut down with a 90 point violation, so it has to be something bad, To get a A you need to get a 0-13 on inspection B is 14-27 C is 28 or more, so a 90 has to be something bad with the place, I called out the place yesterday to see why they got shut down and a guy said something was wrong with the oven like a leak or something, which i dont believe since when La Piazza got shut down, they had a 87 point violation and it was with rats and stuff, so a 90 point violation had to be worse, but just checked the site again and they passed with a 5, so i guess they took care of the problem, but still to have a 90 point violation is BAD, i know dirty places that get are still in business and get a B"

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"Our first time ordering from here, and it was awful. The pizza was described by my teenagers as cardboard with sauce and cheese. I can say that was my first and last time ordering from here"

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"Ordered a pizza today and it was delicious, arrived within 30 minutes piping hot. Will be ordering again."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"i took your advice and went to joe and pats, what a joke, i was a loyal customer for a long time but they are a bunch of arrogant poeple, dont know about justinos or that other third rate pizza place kings lol,thats a laugh. but will never go back to joe &pats, the pizza isnt even good its like eating sauce on a cracker,for 20 dollars not me. and kings not even worth mentioning, thats a train wreck, maybe ill go to brothers at least they are consistent and justinos was just as good."

"January 16, 2020"

donttryitx

"Really great chicken rolls and slices seemed fresh. Very thankful that the new owners replaced Al's as now we finally have some good pizza 'Delivery' on the North shore!"

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"I dunno why my other post got deleted, so im gonna repost this I used to order from here since the food is decent, then again they cant be worse then there competition Kings, Masters, and Paesano's. But one day i decided to go pick up my food and witness with my own eyes, then co owner, making pizza, and let out 3 HUGE sneezes right on the floor by the pizza oven, AND it was opened, it was disgusting, and he continued to make pizza after wards without even washing his hands, i know he didn't use his hands when he sneezed but stillI told the other co owner Joe about it and he was very rude about it, saying he sneezed on the floor its not in the air, stuff like that. I told my friends about this and they said they seen that happened before and they stopped going, looks like me and my friends are going to have to drive a bit for Pizza and go to Brother's on forest avenue Also you noticed the sign inside the stores says Al's Pizzeria and one of the Co owners name is Al Stay away from this place"

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"best pizza ive had in a long time...and the prices are more then reasonable..."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"tried the new justinos where the old al's used to be....the place has been totally renevated, you can actually sit and have a pie...wich we did, amazing!!!!! will be back soon...try the grandma it was great!"

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"thanx to where you eat . com i found the best pizza on staten island. check it out you wont be disapointed"

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"als was better, maybe 25 years ago. lol what a joke! the place was filthy and the pizza un edible. im here 40 years trust me i know,justinos on jewett is a great asset to the area, love their L&B ITV WAS FABULOUS. I GUESS THE PROOF IS IN THE PIZZA, I HEAR THEY ARE DOING A GREAT BUISNESS. We ARE ALL ROOTING FOR YOU GUYS. best of luck"

"January 16, 2020"