Elaine

"Terrible online service and workers are incompetent on making food orders. I'm not sure why this place takes online order's when they don't prepare the food on time for the customer pick up or even prepare the food even at all. Real idiots Don't order from this place !! spend your money else where"

"January 16, 2020"

inferno

"Dear SIgal my apologies that they put prosciutto in your penne ala vodka. please come in and I will give you a credit to purchase anything else you like. We try our hardest to get every order done correctly but unfortunately we do sometimes mess up. As far as the nutella pizza and calzone we do use real nutella but we mix it with mascarpone cheese to give it a creamier texture so the nutella doesn't burn but we will be happy to use pure nutella. As far as our prices we charge a fair value for the quality of product we purchase. We do run Groupon and Amazon local coupons, as well as daily specials like buy one get one often. please call us and we will be happy to tell you what offers we have at the moment. M"

"January 16, 2020"

Corexter

"The previous two reviews for Goodfellas are bogus, probably competitors trying to smash a new business. Anyways many pizzerias in Great Kills offer something unique, which is hard to say for other pizzerias on Staten Island. Goodfellas Inferno is one of them and the specialty pizzas are delicious, very tasty and very unique, I urge you to try it as its a great addition to the community. About being expensive, you can easily have a "regular pizza" here for $10-$11, same as others but the place is known for serving it's specialty pies, even though they are a bit more expensive than the regular New York style pizza, they are worth it. Bogus claim of using "Fake Nutella" is is just ridicoulous. We love Goodfellas and now order on a regular basis, previously we had to drive to Dongon Hills to have it, now its nearby."

"January 16, 2020"

Gemini Man

"They took over from the old Roma Delight, and the food is much much better. The place is very clean and comfortable feeling. I had the veal parm hero and it was perfect. I was there yesterday and I'm going back again today. I can see myself going there at least once a week if not more."

"January 16, 2020"

Ashby1000

"HOLY S#%*!!! DID NOT expect legit goodfellas quality from this place. I feel honored to have this down the block from my house. That buffalo chicken pizza they had was SOOOOOOOOOOO good. My new pizza spot."

"January 16, 2020"

Krissy

"Pizza was sooo delicious !"

"January 16, 2020"