"I like Food. I like good Food. All Star is good Food. I eat at All Star weekly. Great spaghetti and MEATBALLS to die for. Plus it great to be able to have a beer or two and watch TV. Cool in the summer, warm in the winter. Good atmosphere I like both of the girls that work there Good Eats."
"January 16, 2020"
Pizzaluver
"DEEP-DISH I had a cute but unpredictable girlfriend in college with whom I broke up and reunited so many times I lost count. Same thing with All Star. I love it, I hate it, I love it, I have a restraining order against it . . . and lately I’m falling prey to its charms again. The thick, golden crust—its edges famously caramelized into blackened perfection by a thin layer of cheese applied before cooking—is brawny enough to shoulder hefty lumps of secretly blended sausage and a gloriously chunky sweet sauce. Take me back one more time, All Star I’m on my knees."
"January 16, 2020"
ohshush
"Fresh great ingredients,the best spinach & sausage & pepper rolls in SI.
Yes.. a little high priced but well worth it.
DO Not say yes when they ask "sauce on the side?" they charge extra!
Their pizza is good but the rest of the menu is better."
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"Way Overpriced! $14 + tax for a Pie? Way too much garlic, and I love garlic but the Chicken Roll is non-edible which just so much of it. By the way who charges extra for sauce that everyone gives on the side?"
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"The worst pizzeria on Staten Island. Used to be good, now it is horrible."
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"This place is only good for giving the kids a bite when dropping them at the movies. The pizza sucks, you can tell they don't use any quality ingredients in any of their products. If you have the option for ordering or taking out from somewhere else I'll suggest any of the many places available in our area except these guys."
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"This place such rip off and on top of that's they charged tax"
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"Overpriced greasy pizza.. No bueno"
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"New September Deal Alert - Great Value, Large Pie and Entree of Penne with a Side of Meatballs. Feeds for for only $24.95!"
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"This place is awesome. Delicious food and a awesome staff"
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"Hard to find a better place on Staten Island"
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"Fresh ingredients. And delicious"
"January 16, 2020"
All Star Cafe Located in Great Kills neighborhood of Staten Island. All Star Cafe is open Today. Sunday December 29th from 11:30 am -until 08:45 pm Delivery, is available. Serving Pizzeria Cuisine
*WhereYouEat is a local restaurant search engine - we are not necessarily affiliated with any restaurant listed on our guide. We try to maintain accuracy of listings, but the data below is not verified or guaranteed, and may be outdated.
Subscribe to Exclusive WhereYouEat.com Deals for All Star Cafe & Other Nearby Announcements
By submitting your information, you give your Express Consent to receive Recurring Updates from WhereYouEat.com regarding Local Restaurant Promotions, Grand Openings & Other News.
Even if you are on a State or Federal Do-Not-Call List
We will send maximum of 5 Messages per week READ FULL DISCLAIMER
Disclaimer
By submitting your information, you give your Express Consent to receive recurring updates from WhereYouEat.com regarding Local Restaurant Promotions, Grand Openings & Other news. You will receive messages even if you are on any National or Local Do-Not-Call lists.
We won't share your details with any third parties, but may send out promotional messages from third parties looking to promote local restaurant related news, specials, events or happenings.
You Agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Please note that consent to receive messages is not a condition for any purchase. Standard message & data rates may apply. You can opt-out at any time by replying STOP to any of the messages. For additional information you can reply HELP or contact our customer care at 800-865-897
Subscribe for Email and/or Subscribe for SMS phone
"I like Food. I like good Food. All Star is good Food. I eat at All Star weekly. Great spaghetti and MEATBALLS to die for. Plus it great to be able to have a beer or two and watch TV. Cool in the summer, warm in the winter. Good atmosphere I like both of the girls that work there Good Eats."
IlikeFood
"January 16, 2020"
"DEEP-DISH I had a cute but unpredictable girlfriend in college with whom I broke up and reunited so many times I lost count. Same thing with All Star. I love it, I hate it, I love it, I have a restraining order against it . . . and lately I’m falling prey to its charms again. The thick, golden crust—its edges famously caramelized into blackened perfection by a thin layer of cheese applied before cooking—is brawny enough to shoulder hefty lumps of secretly blended sausage and a gloriously chunky sweet sauce. Take me back one more time, All Star I’m on my knees."
Pizzaluver
"January 16, 2020"
"Fresh great ingredients,the best spinach & sausage & pepper rolls in SI.
Yes.. a little high priced but well worth it.
DO Not say yes when they ask "sauce on the side?" they charge extra!
Their pizza is good but the rest of the menu is better."
ohshush
"January 16, 2020"
"Way Overpriced! $14 + tax for a Pie? Way too much garlic, and I love garlic but the Chicken Roll is non-edible which just so much of it. By the way who charges extra for sauce that everyone gives on the side?"
anonymous
"January 16, 2020"
"The worst pizzeria on Staten Island. Used to be good, now it is horrible."
anonymous
"January 16, 2020"
"This place is only good for giving the kids a bite when dropping them at the movies. The pizza sucks, you can tell they don't use any quality ingredients in any of their products. If you have the option for ordering or taking out from somewhere else I'll suggest any of the many places available in our area except these guys."
anonymous
"January 16, 2020"
"This place such rip off and on top of that's they charged tax"
anonymous
"January 16, 2020"
"Overpriced greasy pizza.. No bueno"
anonymous
"January 16, 2020"
"New September Deal Alert - Great Value, Large Pie and Entree of Penne with a Side of Meatballs. Feeds for for only $24.95!"
anonymous
"January 16, 2020"
"This place is awesome. Delicious food and a awesome staff"
All Star Cafe Located in Great Kills neighborhood of Staten Island. All Star Cafe is open Today. Sunday December 29th from 11:30 am -until 08:45 pm Delivery,
Restaurants offering Alcohol/Beer/Wine is available. Serving Pizzeria Cuisine
Near Here Search "694 Arthur Kill Road (Atrium Shopping Complex), Staten Island, NY 10308"
*These Results are "Near Me" search and may contain sponsors part of this result
Our website uses cookies to enhance your browsing experience and provide relevant information. By continuing to use our site, you acknowledge and accept our Cookie Policy & Privacy
9 Photos
.png)
