Your browser does not support JavaScript!
Restaurant Scoop "The Blog"

Posted in Closures | Tags: Brooklyn Italian Heroes Staten Island restaurant closure Terrible Eddie s Annadale Road

Brooklyn Italian Heroes Closes its Doors: What s Next for Staten Island s Food Scene

View restaurant on WhereYouEat Dining Guide
October 07, 2025

The news of Brooklyn Italian Heroes closing its doors at 829 Annadale Rd. in Staten Island marks the end of an era for local sandwich lovers. Known for its crispy bread and hearty fillings, the restaurant has been a staple in the community, offering a wide array of choices for those seeking a satisfying meal.

gallery imageRegular patrons will fondly remember the classic sandwiches with layers of meat and melted cheese. These menu items were more than just food; they were a part of daily life for many in the area, providing comfort and consistency.

Brooklyn Italian Heroes has long been appreciated for its dedication to quality ingredients, as highlighted in its promotional materials. The use of imported prosciutto, cold cuts, and brick oven bread set this establishment apart, drawing in customers who valued authenticity and taste.

The detailed menu offered numerous sandwich options, each crafted with care. From traditional recipes to unique creations, every item was a testament to the culinary vision of Brooklyn Italian Heroes.

With the closure of this beloved eatery, Staten Island residents wonder what will come next. The new venture, Terrible Eddie's, is set to take over the location. While details about the new restaurant are still emerging, anticipation is building for what Terrible Eddie's will bring to the table. The community eagerly awaits its opening and the potential new flavors it will introduce to Annadale Road.

 

From Brooklyn Italian Heroes WhereYouEat Profile Gallery
gallery imagegallery imagegallery image

About Brooklyn Italian Heroes
📍 Located at: 829 Annadale Rd. Staten Island, NY 10312
🔗 View Brooklyn Italian Heroes WhereYouEat Profile  (For Menus, Galleries & Latest Specials)
🌐 Website: order.brooklynitalianheroes3.com

Cookie Consent

Our website uses cookies to enhance your browsing experience and provide relevant information. By continuing to browse this website You agree to our TERMS & CONDITIONS as well as our PRIVACY POLICY