Your browser does not support JavaScript!
Restaurant Scoop "The Blog"

Posted in Reviews | Tags: Sally s Apizza New Haven Pizzeria Takeout Pizza Apizza Fair Haven

A Taste of Tradition: Sally s Apizza in New Haven

View restaurant on WhereYouEat Dining Guide
October 07, 2025

gallery image

 

 

 

 

 

 

As you approach Sally's Apizza on Wooster Street in New Haven, the traditional brick facade and the inviting red umbrella create a welcoming entrance. The signage prominently displays the takeout and pickup options, making it clear that this is a place where convenience meets culinary history.

 

gallery image

 

 

 

gallery image

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The pizza box, adorned with the restaurant's logo and a nod to its storied history since 1938, hints at the authenticity and tradition that Sally's Apizza is known for. It's a reminder of the legacy that this establishment has maintained over the decades.

Opening the pizza box reveals a pizza that immediately sets itself apart with its charred crust and simple topping of tomato sauce and cheese. Unlike traditional pizzas, Sally's Apizza offers a unique taste experience, perhaps the reason behind its distinctive name. The flavors are straightforward yet enjoyable, capturing the essence of what has made this pizzeria a staple in the Fair Haven neighborhood.

For those interested in visiting, Sally's Apizza operates from Sunday, opening at 10:30 am, to Saturday, closing at 10:00 pm. The pizzeria provides both takeout services and a dine-in option with attentive waitstaff, catering to a variety of dining preferences.

 

 

 

 

From Sally's Apizza WhereYouEat Profile Gallery
gallery imagegallery imagegallery image

About Sally's Apizza
📍 Located at: 237 Wooster St, New Haven, CT 06511
🍽️ Restaurants offering Take Out, Restaurants offering Wait Staff/Dine In
🔗 View Sally's Apizza WhereYouEat Profile  (For Menus, Galleries & Latest Specials)

Cookie Consent

Our website uses cookies to enhance your browsing experience and provide relevant information. By continuing to browse this website You agree to our TERMS & CONDITIONS as well as our PRIVACY POLICY