"The steak is great here. i had the 9 inch .They pile on the meat i could not ginish the whole thing. My boyfriend had the brisket. He loved it. My favorite place to eat late. They also have boylan fountian soda first time i ever saw this."
"January 16, 2020"
donttryitx
"Had an excellent cheese steak here the other day, 6" was perfect, the bread was soft and it had plenty of meat and cheese. Be sure to ask for some cherry peppers to add some spiciness to the sandwich."
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"old tasting steak kind of like they reheated it when i ordered it...I'll never go here again.... bring back dairy queen"
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"wow i mean double wow. This place rocks. Steak was juicy and filling. I also tryed there pizza fries awesome. This place is better than philly ..Shaggys steaks is the new king around town. The staff was very nice which is a plus. ILL BE BACK"
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"where can you find a better cheesesteak on staten island. no where. mE AND MY FRIENDS ORDER THEM AND WATCH JERSEY SHORE. CHEESESTEAK TIME. LOL."
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"Saw this place and wondered if it was good. This place is better than good its great. Had the roastpork italian the best sandwich i ever had. next time ill try the steak."
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"Ordered here for my super bowl party. I had the wings. They were great. The wings were not only tasty but they were huge and krispy. Blows away planet wings by a mile. IF YOU LIKE WINGS THIS IS THE BEST PLACE ON STATEN ISLAND. Dint try the cheesesteak yet but i cant wait."
"January 16, 2020"
GenoWhirl
"Cheesesteaks
Although I ordered the cheesesteak without anything but cheese and steak on it, I could clearly taste green pepper. I don't know if they need to clean their grill or move the food a little further away from each other but if I wanted to taste green pepper I would've asked for it. The cheese was fine although I've had better I think it's the same they use in philly though so.... The bread and meat were nothing special. If they do import it from philly maybe they should stop because it's really not helping, I've had equally good bread and steak from Staten Island, probably fresher andor cheaper too.
The meat was a bit overcooked as well. I know it's supposed to be pretty well done but this was a little tough and dry. I've had worse though. Too bad they gave me something like a pound of beef with no cheese surrounded by a bun slathered with cheese instead of layering it or something. It was actually better after I removed some meat.
Mozzarella Sticks
Pretty good you can get similar ones just about anywhere. I only got 5 for $5. Seems a bit pricey to me. I mean, if I offered you a single mozzarella stick for a dollar would you think that sounds like a good deal
Hot Wings
The other person I tried it with got hot wings. She ordered it mild and said it was a bit hot but otherwise pretty good. Amusingly, better than planet wings which I noted isn't saying much.
Onion Rings
These were good.
So that's about it. Not bad except for the cheesesteak and the prices came out to about $12-14 a person, something closer to $8-10 would've been nice."
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"THIS PLACE IS AWESOME. THE STEAK WAS GREAT. I HAD THE 9 INCH AND THE SANDWICH HAD A POUND OF MEAT ON IT. THE BURGERS WERE AMAZING. THEY USE THE SAME MEAT AS SHAKE SHACK IN THE CITY. THE WINGS WERE HUGE AND MEATY. BLOWS PLANET WINGS AWAY. I HEAR THERE OPENING A STORE OUT IN TOTTENVILLE. GOOD LUCK THE BEST FOOD STORE TO HIT STATEN ISLAND IN A LONG TIME. KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK GUYS WE LOVE IT."
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"The place is awesome. YOU GUYS SAVED ME A TRIP TO PHILLY."
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"Ok I Went in wanting a cheesesteak and my girl had the 1/2 pound burger. T he cheesesteak was exellent but the burger was the best burger she ever had. The bun was a martin potatoe bun. The meat was soooo juicy. THIS WILL BE OUR NEW PLACE TO MUNCH OUT."
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"Simply put, this place rocks. So you might have to wait a few minutes for them to cook your order....big deal. The food more than makes up for it and well worth the wait. I am glad I found this place."
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"Whats not to like. The steak was awesome. The service was good. Love that they have eggplant fries. Keep up the good work."
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"Not bad for a NY cheesesteak. I'm originally from Philly and they still don't come close to an authentic Philly cheesesteak like they say. The rolls aren't the typical rolls we use and the meat isn't cut thin enough. Overall though, not a bad sandwich."
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"The food is great, but as of this writing, they've been open for more than 2 months and they still seem to be learning how to operated a business. Missing items from the orders and extensive waiting times.
They can be really great if they just got their system down.
I've been there more than 5 times since they opened and everytime it seems likes it the grand opening. A major part of the problem is the food service setup. Cheesesteaks are cooked in the front while everything else is cooked in back creating a mass confusion when things start to get busy. Another issue is each steak is cooked to order, this extends the wait time even more. If you're trying to be like Genos or Pats, know your surge periods and prepare.
Food- B
Service-F"
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"very disappointed. I was so hoping this place would be great since hubby and i have been looking for a good place for cheesesteaks but sadly this was not it. The meat didn't taste fresh.. it had that "leftover meat" taste."
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"THIS PLACE WAS GREAT THE PLACE IS ALWAYS CROWDED AND WE TRYED THE 9 INCH CHEESESTEAK WITH WIZ. IM HOOKED. THE MEAT WAS JUICY AND PLENTY. THE MEAT WAS COOKED FRESH IN FRONT OF YOU. THE ROAST PORK WAS GOOD TOO. THEY ALSO HAVE BOYLAN SODA."
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"Wow Im so happy i found this place. The steaks are better the Pats and Genos. The place does get busy and you need to wait a while for a sandwich. The frys are awesome and they have great wings. THE STEAK IS SO GOOD MY BOYFRIEND IS ADDICTED. I f you like cheesesteaks this is the place to go."
"January 16, 2020"
Shaggy's Original Cheesesteak-CLOSED Located in New Dorp neighborhood of Staten Island. Shaggy's Original Cheesesteak-CLOSED is open Today. Sunday January 5th from 11:00 am -until 09:00 pm Delivery, is available. Serving American Cuisine
*WhereYouEat is a local restaurant search engine - we are not necessarily affiliated with any restaurant listed on our guide. We try to maintain accuracy of listings, but the data below is not verified or guaranteed, and may be outdated.
Subscribe to Exclusive WhereYouEat.com Deals for Shaggy's Original Cheesesteak-CLOSED & Other Nearby Announcements
By submitting your information, you give your Express Consent to receive Recurring Updates from WhereYouEat.com regarding Local Restaurant Promotions, Grand Openings & Other News.
Even if you are on a State or Federal Do-Not-Call List
We will send maximum of 5 Messages per week READ FULL DISCLAIMER
Disclaimer
By submitting your information, you give your Express Consent to receive recurring updates from WhereYouEat.com regarding Local Restaurant Promotions, Grand Openings & Other news. You will receive messages even if you are on any National or Local Do-Not-Call lists.
We won't share your details with any third parties, but may send out promotional messages from third parties looking to promote local restaurant related news, specials, events or happenings.
You Agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Please note that consent to receive messages is not a condition for any purchase. Standard message & data rates may apply. You can opt-out at any time by replying STOP to any of the messages. For additional information you can reply HELP or contact our customer care at 800-865-897
Subscribe for Email and/or Subscribe for SMS phone
"The steak is great here. i had the 9 inch .They pile on the meat i could not ginish the whole thing. My boyfriend had the brisket. He loved it. My favorite place to eat late. They also have boylan fountian soda first time i ever saw this."
anonymous
"January 16, 2020"
"Had an excellent cheese steak here the other day, 6" was perfect, the bread was soft and it had plenty of meat and cheese. Be sure to ask for some cherry peppers to add some spiciness to the sandwich."
donttryitx
"January 16, 2020"
"old tasting steak kind of like they reheated it when i ordered it...I'll never go here again.... bring back dairy queen"
anonymous
"January 16, 2020"
"wow i mean double wow. This place rocks. Steak was juicy and filling. I also tryed there pizza fries awesome. This place is better than philly ..Shaggys steaks is the new king around town. The staff was very nice which is a plus. ILL BE BACK"
anonymous
"January 16, 2020"
"where can you find a better cheesesteak on staten island. no where. mE AND MY FRIENDS ORDER THEM AND WATCH JERSEY SHORE. CHEESESTEAK TIME. LOL."
anonymous
"January 16, 2020"
"Saw this place and wondered if it was good. This place is better than good its great. Had the roastpork italian the best sandwich i ever had. next time ill try the steak."
anonymous
"January 16, 2020"
"Ordered here for my super bowl party. I had the wings. They were great. The wings were not only tasty but they were huge and krispy. Blows away planet wings by a mile. IF YOU LIKE WINGS THIS IS THE BEST PLACE ON STATEN ISLAND. Dint try the cheesesteak yet but i cant wait."
anonymous
"January 16, 2020"
"Cheesesteaks
Although I ordered the cheesesteak without anything but cheese and steak on it, I could clearly taste green pepper. I don't know if they need to clean their grill or move the food a little further away from each other but if I wanted to taste green pepper I would've asked for it. The cheese was fine although I've had better I think it's the same they use in philly though so.... The bread and meat were nothing special. If they do import it from philly maybe they should stop because it's really not helping, I've had equally good bread and steak from Staten Island, probably fresher andor cheaper too.
The meat was a bit overcooked as well. I know it's supposed to be pretty well done but this was a little tough and dry. I've had worse though. Too bad they gave me something like a pound of beef with no cheese surrounded by a bun slathered with cheese instead of layering it or something. It was actually better after I removed some meat.
Mozzarella Sticks
Pretty good you can get similar ones just about anywhere. I only got 5 for $5. Seems a bit pricey to me. I mean, if I offered you a single mozzarella stick for a dollar would you think that sounds like a good deal
Hot Wings
The other person I tried it with got hot wings. She ordered it mild and said it was a bit hot but otherwise pretty good. Amusingly, better than planet wings which I noted isn't saying much.
Onion Rings
These were good.
So that's about it. Not bad except for the cheesesteak and the prices came out to about $12-14 a person, something closer to $8-10 would've been nice."
GenoWhirl
"January 16, 2020"
"THIS PLACE IS AWESOME. THE STEAK WAS GREAT. I HAD THE 9 INCH AND THE SANDWICH HAD A POUND OF MEAT ON IT. THE BURGERS WERE AMAZING. THEY USE THE SAME MEAT AS SHAKE SHACK IN THE CITY. THE WINGS WERE HUGE AND MEATY. BLOWS PLANET WINGS AWAY. I HEAR THERE OPENING A STORE OUT IN TOTTENVILLE. GOOD LUCK THE BEST FOOD STORE TO HIT STATEN ISLAND IN A LONG TIME. KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK GUYS WE LOVE IT."
anonymous
"January 16, 2020"
"The place is awesome. YOU GUYS SAVED ME A TRIP TO PHILLY."
anonymous
"January 16, 2020"
"Ok I Went in wanting a cheesesteak and my girl had the 1/2 pound burger. T he cheesesteak was exellent but the burger was the best burger she ever had. The bun was a martin potatoe bun. The meat was soooo juicy. THIS WILL BE OUR NEW PLACE TO MUNCH OUT."
anonymous
"January 16, 2020"
"Simply put, this place rocks. So you might have to wait a few minutes for them to cook your order....big deal. The food more than makes up for it and well worth the wait. I am glad I found this place."
anonymous
"January 16, 2020"
"Whats not to like. The steak was awesome. The service was good. Love that they have eggplant fries. Keep up the good work."
anonymous
"January 16, 2020"
"Not bad for a NY cheesesteak. I'm originally from Philly and they still don't come close to an authentic Philly cheesesteak like they say. The rolls aren't the typical rolls we use and the meat isn't cut thin enough. Overall though, not a bad sandwich."
anonymous
"January 16, 2020"
"The food is great, but as of this writing, they've been open for more than 2 months and they still seem to be learning how to operated a business. Missing items from the orders and extensive waiting times.
They can be really great if they just got their system down.
I've been there more than 5 times since they opened and everytime it seems likes it the grand opening. A major part of the problem is the food service setup. Cheesesteaks are cooked in the front while everything else is cooked in back creating a mass confusion when things start to get busy. Another issue is each steak is cooked to order, this extends the wait time even more. If you're trying to be like Genos or Pats, know your surge periods and prepare.
Food- B
Service-F"
anonymous
"January 16, 2020"
"very disappointed. I was so hoping this place would be great since hubby and i have been looking for a good place for cheesesteaks but sadly this was not it. The meat didn't taste fresh.. it had that "leftover meat" taste."
anonymous
"January 16, 2020"
"THIS PLACE WAS GREAT THE PLACE IS ALWAYS CROWDED AND WE TRYED THE 9 INCH CHEESESTEAK WITH WIZ. IM HOOKED. THE MEAT WAS JUICY AND PLENTY. THE MEAT WAS COOKED FRESH IN FRONT OF YOU. THE ROAST PORK WAS GOOD TOO. THEY ALSO HAVE BOYLAN SODA."
anonymous
"January 16, 2020"
"Wow Im so happy i found this place. The steaks are better the Pats and Genos. The place does get busy and you need to wait a while for a sandwich. The frys are awesome and they have great wings. THE STEAK IS SO GOOD MY BOYFRIEND IS ADDICTED. I f you like cheesesteaks this is the place to go."
Shaggy's Original Cheesesteak-CLOSED Located in New Dorp neighborhood of Staten Island. Shaggy's Original Cheesesteak-CLOSED is open Today. Sunday January 5th from 11:00 am -until 09:00 pm Delivery,
Restaurants offering Alcohol/Beer/Wine is available. Serving American Cuisine
Our website uses cookies to enhance your browsing experience and provide relevant information. By continuing to use our site, you acknowledge and accept our Cookie Policy & Privacy