"Beware, that this restaurant does not honor the prices listed on this website."

"March 23, 2022"

"Andrews food A+ Their attention to detail is unmatched, No exaggeration. The burger fresh, super large portion, fries light n airy fried in clean oil, the lettuce n tom crispy& fresh. They always add plenty of ketchup salt pepper n sides of coleslaw etc… their prices also remain fair n lower than anywhere else. I cannot remember a bad delivery in decades! Ty Andrews Diner. One of few dependable solid quality restaurant still standing in its league, while most have cut on quality portions or raised prices to crazy high…"

"March 03, 2022"

"You people can’t get a simple order right. This second time you forgot items. Why Don’t you have someone who pays attention taking orders. Very frustrating especially After leaving 20% tip NEVER AGAIN"

"December 27, 2021"

"Ever since the hylan diner opened it has blown it out the park and set my standards higher, even though there’s always a wait it’s a lot better, sorry andrew"

"May 01, 2021"

anonymous

""

"March 04, 2020"

anonymous

"AWESOME FOOD.. ITS IS GREAT. I TOTALLY RECOMMENDED IT FOR PEOPLE WHO LIKE TO BE SERVED IN A GOOD MANNER!!"

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"Great Diner. Great food huge portions nice atmosphere,very clean good sercice and fair prices."

"January 16, 2020"

mancini

"Used to love this place and would choose it over the other local diners. Food is still good, but its not worth talking to the rude lady who takes my phone order, rushes u off the phone,and then gets it wrong. They have become too much of a factory where they just want your money and to rush you out the door instead of giving you a full dining experience.. and theyre pricey!"

"January 16, 2020"

Marcella

"I don't recall ever having eaten something that wasn't fresh and very good at this diner. It's a great place!"

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"our favorite staten island diner. all the servers are very friendly, food tastes homemade. ingredients are always fresh, never had a bad meal there. only complaint is that the hostess seems to favor certain people over others when there are large groups waiting, and is very brusque."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"this place is so good, i love it, drive all the way from willowbrook. this is the only diner that i see people eat clams in and it actually looks smells and tastes good. two problems parking and not open late"

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"One of the best burgers on the island"

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"Everytime I order for delivery, they either screw up the order or forget stuff. The woman that takes the order is not very friendly either."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"its a great place"

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"What an amazing restaurant. I cannot begin to describe how pleasurable it is eating here, I will try to just describe the food. For $19.95 me and my husband ordered their "Fisherman's Special" or something along those lines.. We decided to split it as per waitresses suggestion, The Entrée came with a huge piece of Salmon which could have been a meal by itself, 2 Large Fillet of Sole, 2 Stuffed Shrimp, Scallops, Side of Spinach, Stuffed tomato with Feta Cheese. In addition to all of that it also came with a salad, baked potato and bread/bread-sticks. We left stuffed and still had plenty left for lunch today. I don't know these guys profit margins or how they can afford to give so much delicious food, it would have cost us much more to make this ourselves. I guess this is the reason they are always busy and everyone always raves about Andrew's Diner. Can't wait to go back."

"January 16, 2020"

donttryitx

"The food is always good, over sized portions, huge family dinners, very tasty pannini's. The service is always great, fast delivery, Friendly workers. But then again you already know this place is always 'Busy'. One of my Favorite Diners on Staten Island."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"Unfortunately Andrews diner has spoiled us so much that we are not able to order from any other diner in the nearby area. We have tried the broiled seafood dinner from every diner within delivery to us, last time we cheated on andrews with richmond diner, we recieved medium sized shrimp, tiny pieces of salmon and filet and inedible mini scallops. $40 with a club sandwich and no bonuses, breads of anything.. From Andrews we recieve large piece of filet and large deliciously broiled salmon along with jumbo shrimp and large tasty scallops. I must add the delicious stuffed crab along with tomato and feta which just gives more oomph to the dish. Always served with lemons, breads and breadsticks. Andrews is about $2 or $3 more but there is enough food for the next day and it is constantly delicious. Let me add where andrew spoils us. Along with serving huge portions and always well cooked quality food about 80% of the time we get a pastry which makes breakfast the next day so delightful. We will no longer cheat on yiu Andrews, just please don't change on us."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"I live just a few blocks away and me and my family order very frequently. You can always count on the food being of high quality and quantity. The staff is very professional and no matter how busy they are, they take the time to make sure they get the orders right. Love, love, love Andrews!"

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"Simply the best diner on Staten Island. Great food and a fantastic, professional staff."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"We always went to andrews for breakfast,lunch and dinner but since I had a stroke 6 years ago we have been ordering from them for delivery at least twice a week. Wednesday for their beef barley soup and Saturday or Sunday.the food is consistently excellent. I wish he would addstuffed peppers andquiche to the menu. Best burgers around. Love this diner try it snd you will agree"

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"We always loved this diners food but lately their food hasn't been the same. We ordered lamb chops dinner that wasn't cheep, but it was very tough to chew and dry.won't be ordering soon. Disappointed."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"Used to be very good, good and price. Now higher than all other diners. Prices listed on website menu incorrect. Yesterday I ordered a roastbeef sandwich listed at $11.00 I was charged $13.00. When I ordered a piece of Carrot Cake for delivery three weeks ago, they now cut the piece in half. When George retires, I will miss him. At this rate, I think the end is near for the diner."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"To the previous reviews, the prices are higher than other diners by about one to two dollars, but they give you soooo much more. I wish other diners would give you as much as they do for the few dollars higher per dish."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"We used to go at least once a week here but since my stroke we order take out at least once or twice a week now especially on wed when they have the beef barley soup. Omg it's so good. Every Wednesday without fail.food is excellent .hsmburhers the best. Everything hot snd delicious. Quality and service perfect. We miss going there but take out is great."

"January 16, 2020"