"We tried Hook & Reel for the first time and enjoyed it so much, we went back 2 days later. The food was well prepared, delicious, and served hot. Yummy lobster bisque, I ordered a 2nd bowl after finishing the first! Fried calamari was yummy as well. The raw oysters were perfect and the boil with Hook & Reel's own Cajun sauce was outstanding. Our server, Moe, was friendly and very efficient; he makes your dining experience error-free so you can relax and enjoy the meal. The Manager here is friendly and really appreciates the customers. You will definitely want to eat here frequently. Great service, tasty food, relaxed atmosphere - you won't be disappointed."

"August 21, 2022"

anonymous

"I thought this was a complete ripoff. 50 dollars for a bucket of crab legs, blue crabs, shrimp and 2 potatoes 2 corn and six sausages. Crab legs were good size, however the waiter insisted that we order the blue crab because it had more meat. Even tried charge more which the restaurant caught. Blue crab had NO MEAT and fish eggs and when confronted the waiter admitted that he NEVER tried them. So how is there more meat in something you NEVER tried. Had to get my own cracker and small forks. Potato was a small round potato not a baked potato size. Sausages were like those from a can and soft. The seafood was not bad quality, however the QUANTITY was completely lacking. They have the nerve to charge 4 dollars extra if you want the head of the shrimp chopped off. WOW! NEVER AGAIN!! Go to a Chinese Buffet if you want the same seafood but unlimited. Let me go eat a sandwich now since I'm starving after my $50 so called dinner. DISGRACEFUL. I predict that this will not last in Staten Island!!! Another waiter even complained to us that he had chicken tenders for lunch and got three pieces of chicken in his basket. Are they kidding. BUYER BEWARE."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"Food came out in a bag that looked like a garbage bag.. waited very long for my order.. waiter never came around to ask if i wanted a refill.. over priced.. sausage was horrible.. and potato was so tiny ! Save your money."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"The prices are high which is fine if you’re getting decent seafood. I ordered a combo... crab legs, mussels, shrimp. The mussels were tinted a strange color, which leaked onto my fingers and 3 of them had giant beards still attached. These should have been cleaned, and it was evident that they weren’t. The crab legs, corn and potato were good but I lost my appetite after seeing the uncleanes mussels. Won’t be going back."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"My family and I had a very good time there. The waiter was very nice and checked up on us. The food came out very quickly and was delicious. It was overall a great experience with all the new seafood we had tried. Food was hot and flavorful. Highly recommend trying this restaurant."

"January 16, 2020"