Cookie Jar Restaurant in Staten Island / Menus & Photos

Cookie Jar

Favorite

+ Try List

1226 Forest Ave Staten Island, NY, 10310
718-448-3500 Visit Website

20 Photos

Events

No event found.

"wow cookie jar was just superb. the selection of their different cookies are just awesome and mouth watering. i love those cookies with almond in particular because almonds are my favorite. their cookies are sweet and nice. Cookie jar should be visited by cookie headed people. it is simply the cookie heaven."

"January 16, 2020"

Hitchmagoo

"A little bit of heaven on Forest Ave. I've brought their cookies to many functions and each time had positive feedback. The cookies are great. 100% recommend"

"January 16, 2020"

*Ads

See Everyday Specials, Specialty Pies, Pasta’s and Full Menu

Italian Touch Manor Heights

Info about Content Below

Gallery See All Add Photos

Recent Opening Nearby

OPENED: June 2025

El Xelaju Mexican Guatemala Bakery And Taqueria

809 Castleton Ave, NY 10310

OPENED: May 2025

Rancherita Restaurant

1400 Forest Ave, NY 10302

OPENED: April 2025

Crash Food Truck

111 Jewett Ave, NY 10302

OPENED: February 2025

Johns Deli & Dough

15 Innis St, NY 10302

Subscribe to Exclusive WhereYouEat.com Deals for Cookie Jar & Other Nearby Announcements

By submitting your information, you give your Express Consent to receive Recurring Updates from WhereYouEat.com regarding Local Restaurant Promotions, Grand Openings & Other News.
Even if you are on a State or Federal Do-Not-Call List
We will send maximum of 5 Messages per week READ FULL DISCLAIMER

By signing up via text, you agree to receive recurring restaurant specials from this restaurant and other local restaurants in this area.
Consent is not a condition of purchase.
Reply STOP to unsubscribe.
Reply HELP for help.
Message frequency varies. Msg & Data rates may apply. View our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

Message Delivery powered by WhereYouEat.com
*Standard Message Rates may apply
*Unsubscribe to SMS/Messages by Replying "STOP"

See what people are saying Write Review View All Reviews

berCAB44

"January 16, 2020"

"A little bit of heaven on Forest Ave. I've brought their cookies to many functions and each time had positive feedback. The cookies are great. 100% recommend"

Hitchmagoo

"January 16, 2020"

Location & Details

Cookie Jar Located in Castleton Corners neighborhood of Staten Island. Cookie Jar is open Today. Friday June 13th from 11:00 am -until 09:00 pm Delivery, Restaurants offering Alcohol/Beer/Wine is available. Serving Desserts Cuisine

1226 Forest Ave , 10310
718-448-3500 Visit Website