"Don't know how good their pizza is because I've been trying to call & place a pick up order for almost an hour. The line is either busy or no one pucks it up"

"April 01, 2022"

"for 40 plus years i've been a customer at brothers i've eaten italian food all over the country and none comes close to brothers. the spaghetti with clams calamari and shrimp marinara is second to none."

"January 18, 2021"

""

"January 18, 2021"

"for 40 plus years i've been a customer at brother's and eaten italian food all over the country and not one is even close to how good brothers is. the spaghetti with clams calamari and shrimp is especially second to none. andy"

"January 18, 2021"

Paoluccio

""

"March 04, 2020"

anonymous

"I've been going to Brother's since I'm born and I would say the past 6 or so years it's gone so down hill. Pizza isn't that great only thing I still enjoy are the garlic knots. They're so overpriced, service could be a LOT better. I called to place an order for pickup and was immediately hung up on and then when I called back they recognized my voice and hung up again! The thing that really made me not go there anymore was during Hurricane Sandy they were selling pies for 25$! That's so f-ing disturbing to me. You make all that money and overcharge during a crisis. Shoulda been giving them away for free."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"I've been going to Brother's since I'm born and I would say the past 6 or so years it's gone so down hill. Pizza isn't that great only thing I still enjoy are the garlic knots. They're so overpriced, service could be a LOT better. I called to place an order for pickup and was immediately hung up on and then when I called back they recognized my voice and hung up again! The thing that really made me not go there anymore was during Hurricane Sandy they were selling pies for 25$! That's so f-ing disturbing to me. You make all that money and overcharge during a crisis. Shoulda been giving them away for free."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"I've been going to Brother's since I'm born and I would say the past 6 or so years it's gone so down hill. Pizza isn't that great only thing I still enjoy are the garlic knots. They're so overpriced, service could be a LOT better. I called to place an order for pickup and was immediately hung up on and then when I called back they recognized my voice and hung up again! The thing that really made me not go there anymore was during Hurricane Sandy they were selling pies for 25$! That's so f-ing disturbing to me. You make all that money and overcharge during a crisis. Shoulda been giving them away for free."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"I've been going to Brother's since I'm born and I would say the past 6 or so years it's gone so down hill. Pizza isn't that great only thing I still enjoy are the garlic knots. They're so overpriced, service could be a LOT better. I called to place an order for pickup and was immediately hung up on and then when I called back they recognized my voice and hung up again! The thing that really made me not go there anymore was during Hurricane Sandy they were selling pies for 25$! That's so f-ing disturbing to me. You make all that money and overcharge during a crisis. Shoulda been giving them away for free."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"I've been going to Brother's since I'm born and I would say the past 6 or so years it's gone so down hill. Pizza isn't that great only thing I still enjoy are the garlic knots. They're so overpriced, service could be a LOT better. I called to place an order for pickup and was immediately hung up on and then when I called back they recognized my voice and hung up again! The thing that really made me not go there anymore was during Hurricane Sandy they were selling pies for 25$! That's so f-ing disturbing to me. You make all that money and overcharge during a crisis. Shoulda been giving them away for free."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"I've been going to Brother's since I'm born and I would say the past 6 or so years it's gone so down hill. Pizza isn't that great only thing I still enjoy are the garlic knots. They're so overpriced, service could be a LOT better. I called to place an order for pickup and was immediately hung up on and then when I called back they recognized my voice and hung up again! The thing that really made me not go there anymore was during Hurricane Sandy they were selling pies for 25$! That's so f-ing disturbing to me. You make all that money and overcharge during a crisis. Shoulda been giving them away for free."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"I grew up eating pizza in Brooklyn. Spumoni Gardens, good pizza, all the others from fair to good, but my favorite pizza is and will always be Brothers pizza. If the family sells the business or decides to move I will be devastated, but for now Brothers is my number 1 pizzeria. I have eaten at Joe and pats and Danino's, nothing beats Brothers pizza. You should see this place during Lent, it's just crazy busy. The only thing missing is delivery, I would love if they delivered. God bless you guys and continue the good job."

"January 16, 2020"

bkarate215

"attitude However, I will begin with the order over the phone. The store now has a dominant staff of Mexicans, who evidently have not mastered the English language. My wife had to repeat the order so many times that she had to ask for an interpreter. When arriving to pick up the order it was chaos because I increased the order by one shrimp. Wow you would have thought I asked them to crack the atom. Then it became a issue of price, which they meaning the Mexicans thought, that five dollars more to the order was going to break the bank. They kept repeating it to each other because they saw I was getting annoyed. Customer treatment is a key requisite for me so its "Nos vemos" NOT."

"January 16, 2020"

Corexter

"The Sicilian Pizza is the best I have ever tasted in the world. There is no question of that, there is just a question of how do they do it, what makes it so good is what I want to find out... Other restaurants use the same cheese, sauce and flour, what do they do that makes it so good?"

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"The island has some of the best pizza I ever tasted, but when I come here Brother's pizza is what I am craving, it's what makes the flight enjoyable, how we discuss the pie we will be ordering after some rest. Sicilian does it."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"Best pizza on the island, hands down!"

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"I would love to give this place 5 stars, the pizza is delicious. Sicilian squares and regular slices are to die for and I mean that. And yes I even understand the high price tag $2.50 for a slice, but the reason I am giving it 4 stars is because the slice should be larger. Sometimes when you get the square slices they are just tiny and on very few occasions you get the regular sized slice. But I must admit that I still many times go out of my way to get it but I have to get 3 slices just to give me the somewhat feeling of being full."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"As a teen I ate Brothers nearly every day. While in the Navy I was stationed in Conneticut and I would drive 2 hours just for a slice and then turn around and drive back. Though I no longer live on Staten Is. I can still taste their pizza. For the past 23 yrs I have lived in Atlanta GA. and there is some decent pizza, but it will never be Brothers. Thanks for one of the greatest experinces about growing up on Staten Is. One day I will make it back for a slice. Sam Rodriguez"

"January 16, 2020"

toastedsalt

"I`ve only had the pizza and it is fantastic. I wish these guys delivered!!!"

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"Sicilian slices are guilt free at Brother's, just because they taste so good you won't ever regret eating here. Their chicken rolls are yummy as well"

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"Brothers is a top 3 pizza spot on staten island, pan slices are just unreal how good they are, the plain slices although for some reason are not that special, go for square or Pan and you will agree it's good"

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"Ordered large pie on Sat. 3/31 half red and half white. It was very greasy, mozzarella cheese was falling off crust. Brothers used to have cheaper and much better quality. This pie wasn't cheap either $19.00"

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"I just bought food it it was suppose to be 25 dollars"

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"This is the best pizza on Staten Island, everything here is absolutely delicious..never disappointed.my family has been coming here for 25 years...well worth getting in your car to pick up????"

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"Best squares I ever had!"

"January 16, 2020"