Type in your address to see what's near you

Staten Island Most trusted Restaurant Menu Guide


Advance search
Click the letters to search

Search By


718-442-8729

Gatsby's on the Bay

Address :
695 Bay Street
Staten Island, 10304
Phone : 718-442-8729

Gatsby's on the Bay Open

Gatsby's on the Bay Open Now

695 Bay Street
Staten Island, NY, 10304
Location : Stapleton

Price Range

718-442-8729

Today's Hours : 12:00PM to 10:00PM

view all

Cuisine : American, 

Services :
Alcohol/Beer/WineWait Staff/Dine InCatering

Features : Participants, Restaurant & Bar, On Site Parking

Type of Place : , 

 100% Like it?

out of 1 votes

How about you ?

Average Review Rating :

Gatsby's on the Bay Description

Enjoy Mouth Watering Food to delightful drinks that awaken your taste buds, allow yourself to transcend your everyday life, release your burdens and cross the threshold from average to exception.  Enjoy Gatsby's on the Bay and have a roaring good time!
View our Video
Pre-Fixe Dine in Special
$19.20 Tuesday - Thursday 3pm to 7pm

Some Dishes from Gatsby's on the Bay


695 Bay Street
Staten Island, NY, 10304
Location : Stapleton

Price Range

718-442-8729


Today's Hours : 12:00PM to 10:00PM

(Now Open)

view all

Cuisine : American, 


Services :
Alcohol/Beer/WineWait Staff/Dine InCatering

Features : Participants, Restaurant & Bar, On Site Parking


Type of Place : , 

 100% Like it?

out of 1 votes

Average Review Rating:



SHARE

695 Bay Street
Staten Island, NY, 10304 Location : Stapleton

Price Range

718-442-8729

Today's Hours : 12:00PM to 10:00PM

view all

Cuisine : American, 

Services :
Alcohol/Beer/WineWait Staff/Dine InCatering

Features : Participants, Restaurant & Bar, On Site Parking

Type of Place : , 

 100% Like it?

out of 1 votes

How about you ?

Average Review Rating :

Gatsby's on the Bay Description

Enjoy Mouth Watering Food to delightful drinks that awaken your taste buds, allow yourself to transcend your everyday life, release your burdens and cross the threshold from average to exception.  Enjoy Gatsby's on the Bay and have a roaring good time!
View our Video
Pre-Fixe Dine in Special
$19.20 Tuesday - Thursday 3pm to 7pm

Some Dishes from Gatsby's on the Bay

No coupons
Write a Review

User Reviews

  • Review Rating :
    Reviewed by :

    anonymous

    On

    12/13/2014
    Review :

    Unique spot with a great atmosphere and excellent food.

    Like :
    Dislike :
    Do you find this Review Helpful?
  • Review Rating :
    Reviewed by :

    anonymous

    On

    11/29/2014
    Review :

    First read about this 1920's style restaurant mentioned in the New York Times--sounded classy and different. Liked it immediately when we walked in--early on a Friday eve it was pretty empty. Nice, warm, relaxing period decor. They have a handbook on the tables to read about the different cocktails from the era. We ordered the elderberry collins, expecting something unusual. It was a drink so good, it would be worth going back just to get another one. Really well done, and served in mason jars--an authentic tribute to the Prohibition Era. The food was delicious, obviously made with care. Served piping hot, and we just generally had the feeling that someone really gave a damn about how this place was run. Overall, an unusual find for Staten Island. Service was excellent. Only negative was there were fruit flies or something similar flying around--an issue that needs to be addressed and I assume it will be taken care of in short order. They have a Prix Fix menu for about $20 during the week, but not the weekends. I highly recommend you check this place out.

    Like :
    Dislike :
    Do you find this Review Helpful?
  • Review Rating :
    Reviewed by :

    anonymous

    On

    08/13/2014
    Review :

    This is my new favorite restaurant on Staten Island. From the decor to the dessert, I'm in love. Adorable outdoor eating area, exposed brick, PERFECT music all greet you upon walking in. Comfortable sized tables and super high ceilings.

    Getting to the important stuff, the food. Party of 5 ordered 3 appetizers: Mac and cheese : perfect. Calamari : capers and jalapenos?! Oh my goodness... French onion soup that you could tell was expertly made.

    Entrees we ordered: seafood risotto : gigantic portion. A little rich for my taste, but delicious. Short ribs : recommended by our waiter and we're incredibly tender with layers and layers of flavor. Duck breast : again, layers of flavor and tenderness (outstanding chutney on top too. Mmm). Prime rib : rivals the hardcore steakhouses on the island.

    Add on the exceptional service and delicious desserts (and watermelon sangria!!!), absolutely do not miss this gem.

    To long time islanders: the chef is formerly of the American Grill on forest avenue. No wonder it's fabulous.

    GO GO GO!!!!!

    Like :
    Dislike :
    Do you find this Review Helpful?
  • Review Rating :
    Reviewed by :

    Tommy135

    On

    01/26/2014
    Review :

    What a nice addition to Staten island, a
    Must go! Delicious food one of a kind atmosphere love everything!
    If your a sangria or delicious interesting drink live you must go

    Like :
    service a+ food a++!!
    Dislike :
    Do you find this Review Helpful?
  • Review Rating :
    Reviewed by :

    mangia

    On

    10/23/2013
    Review :

    The atmosphere is really different and it brings you back to the 1920's. They had a live jazz band playing on a friday nite which had a cool vibe.We had the mussels with bacon polenta and pear salad appetizers. For entrees we had salmon, and short ribs. All were delicious, and also very good sangria. The owner is very nice and friendly. Im looking forward to going back.

    Like :
    Dislike :
    Do you find this Review Helpful?
  • Review Rating :
    Reviewed by :

    kzs8284

    On

    09/16/2013
    Review :

    Great restaurant! Really fresh food, innovative dishes and great drinks! The owner and staff are all very nice. Went twice in one week, we are definitely coming back. They also have different movie nights, jazz nights etc. Make your way down asap!

    Like :
    Dislike :
    Do you find this Review Helpful?
No critics

Gatsby’s On The Bay

 

Starters

 

PEI Mussels white wine, herbs, creamy onion bacon polenta
Tuna Tartar fresh tuna, capers, fresh seaweed, pickled ginger, mango, avocado, tomato, wasabi citrus sauce
Forest Mushroom Pot Pie assortment of mushroom, asparagus, roasted shallots, cream sauce, puff pastry
Gatsby’s Tower fresh mozzarella, tomato, baby arugula, prosciutto, roasted pepper, balsamic glaze, EVOO
Fried Calamari T&T calamari, hot cherry pepper, caper
Beer Battered Fried Shrimp peach, coconut, sweet chili dipping sauce
Truffle Mac and Cheese elbow macaroni, creamy cheese sauce, truffle oil, buttery crumb
Caesar Salad hearts of romaine, parmesan crisp, croutons, traditional homemade Caesar dressing
The Great Gatsby Salad roasted beet, pan fried goat cheese, arugula, walnuts, blackberry balsamic vinaigrette
Blue Cheese and Plum Salad mixed greens, dried cranberries, almond, nectarine, blue cheese crumble, white balsamic vinaigrette
Baby Spinach red onion, sliced mushroom, bacon bits, fried egg, ranch dressing
Soup of the Day ask your server about our chef’s daily special
 

Entrees

 

Sesame Salmon mixed greens, crunchy vegetable, avocado, orange, ginger, soy vinaigrette
Branzino roasted fresh whole fish, fresh thyme, asparagus, risotto
Mixed Seafood Risotto mussels, baby clams, shrimp, white wine, clam broth, seasoned risotto, julienned vegetables
Penne Italian sausage, broccoli rabe, roasted pepper, parmesan cheese, garlic, EVOO
Half Boneless Chicken paprika and herbs, garlic, lemon white wine sauce, mashed potatoes, green bean, fried leeks
Chicken Breast rice, avocado, mango, tomato relish
Duck Breast plum, nectarine, cherry chutney, mashed potato, julienned carrots
Pork Pillard baby spinach, peach, walnuts, strawberry, blue cheese crumble, black balsamic vinaigrette
Boneless Short Ribs red wine, herbs, fried quartered Idaho potato, julienned carrots
The Great Gatsby Skirt Steak mashed potatoes, asparagus, fried leeks, chimichuri sauce
Bone in Ribeye (18 oz) buttermilk crispy fried onions, sautéed spinach, hand cut fries
 

Sides

 

Broccoli Rabe
Asparagus
Rice
Green Beans
Hand Cut Fried Potato Wedges
 

Steven D. Smith, Executive Chef

 

Temperature Guidelines

 

Rare

Very red / cool center
Medium Rare

Red with warm center
Medium

Pink center
Medium

Slightly pink
Well

No pink
 

Consumer Advisory: Consumption of undercooked meat, poultry, eggs, or seafood may increase the risk of foodborne illnesses. Alert your server if you have special dietary requirements.

 

Gatsby’s On The Bay

Make your life tasty

 

Starters

 

Steamed PEI Mussels white wine, herbs, creamy onion bacon polenta
Gatsby’s Tower fresh mozzarella, tomato, baby arugula, prosciutto, roasted pepper, balsamic glaze, EVOO
Mushroom Pot Pie assortment of mushroom, asparagus, roasted shallots, cream sauce, puff pastry
Baked Risotto Cake prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, roasted pepper pesto
Fried Calamari hot peppers, capers
Beer Battered Shrimp peach, coconut, sweet chili sauce
Truffle Mac and Cheese elbow macaroni, cream cheese sauce, truffle oil, buttery crumb topping
Soup of the day ask your server about our chef’s daily special
 

Salads

 

Pork Pillard baby spinach, peach, walnuts, strawberry, blue cheese crumble, blackberry balsamic vinaigrette
Blackened Salmon mixed greens, roasted pepper, roasted corn, tomato, fried tortilla strips, chipotle ranch
Sesame Ahi-Tuna mixed greens, crunchy vegetables, avocado, orange, ginger, soy vinaigrette
Grilled Chicken Caesar hearts of romaine, parmesan crisp
Herb Grilled Shrimp arugula, beets, almonds, panfried goat cheese, nectarine, white balsamic vinaigrette
 

Sandwiches

Includes your choice of mixed green salad or fresh cut fries

 

Gatsby’s 8oz Sirloin Burger bacon, American cheese
Grilled Chicken Panini roasted pepper, fresh mozzarella, balsamic glaze
Skirt Steak Wrap tomato, red onion, arugula, chimi-churi aioli
Cornmeal Fried Tilapia Chibata avocado, tomato, organic field greens, mango, chipotle mayo
Hot Pastrami Reuben butter toasted rye, sauerkraut, thousand island, gruyere Swiss
 

Entrees

 

Chicken Pot Pie carrots, asparagus, potato, mushroom, veloute sauce, puff pastry
American Classic Fried Chicken boneless empire chicken, mashed potatoes, carrots
Individual Meat Loaf caramelized onion, mushroom sauce, mashed potatoes, julienned vegetables
Mixed Seafood Linguini white wine sauce, fresh herbs, linguini
Grilled Ribeye buttermilk fried onions, sautéed spinach, hand cut steak fries
 

Gatsby’s On The Bay

 

Our History

 

Men and girls came and went like moths among the whisperings and the champagne and the stars….The bar is in full swing, and floating rounds of cocktails permeate the garden outside, until the air is alive with chatter and laughter….The lights grow brighter as the earth lurches away from the sun…

 

F. Scott Fitzgerald

 

Four friends captivated by the 1920’s American tradition of gathering in joyous merriment, aspired to make their dreams come true. They became fascinated with the lifestyle celebrated in the 20’s era, often imagining immersing themselves in this time period, fantasizing about a place where this dream would become a reality: Where people could come together to celebrate life. The seed was planted and the vision began to develop. From these wishes Gatsby’s on the Bay was born. From hard-work, commitment, and determination, they now ecstatically extend an invitation towards you to join in on the festivities. From mouth-watering food to delightful drinks to awaken your taste buds, allow yourself to transcend your everyday life, release your burdens, and cross the threshold from average to exceptional. We invite you to be our guest, have a roaring good time!

 

 

Staten Island Restaurants | Brooklyn Restaurants