We are listed on
best restaurant finder in Newyork
Brooklyn & Staten Islands Local Dining Guide
PLEASE SELECT CITY TO SEARCH - BEFORE SEARCHING Thank You :)

WhereYouEat
The Local Dining Guid

My Account

Restaurant Management

Support(800.865.8997)

Get in touch
Type in your address to see what's near you
Advance search
Click the letters to search
718-865-8021

For pick up and delivery:

Order Online

Brooklyn's Finest

Address :
1250 Hylan Blvd
Staten Island, 10305
Phone : 718-865-8021

For pick up and delivery:

Order Online

Brooklyn's Finest Closed

16 Photos
1250 Hylan Blvd,
, 10305


Today's Hours : 08:00AM to 10:30PM

718-865-8021

Pizzeria, , Lunch Specials, Online Ordering, , , DeliveryCateringTake OutAlcohol/Beer/Wine

Message from Brooklyn's Finest

A large variety of tasty and authentic dishes.  Always fresh and always using only the top ingredients. Now Serving Beer!

Brooklyn's Finest accepts Online Ordering
For Delivery and Pick Up
Click here to Order Online
restaurant menu
restaurant menu
restaurant menu
restaurant menu
restaurant menu
restaurant menu
restaurant menu

Gallery

Dishes

If you pay attention to review dates and volume compared to other places, you will see they are bogus. In addition, the bad reviews still show five stars. The pizza here is bad! The sandwiches are bland. The calzones are undercooked. Artichokes taste like can. Delivery/service is fine.


Kitchen prepared food is out on display making a quick stop for a home meal. Brooklyn's Finest is by far the best restaurant on this side of the island - and notice how I didn't say "pizzeria" because it is more than a pizzeria. Their kitchen entree's taste better than the restaurant next door, no pun intended, they are just that good.


The restaurant is more than a pizzeria, they have delicious kitchen food which I have not found anywhere else, pannelle sandwich was out of this world and heroes are as well


delivery service is terrible


I did not care for the food here at all. Definitely one of the worse pizza places I have been to. Sorry. Def. Not the finest Brooklyn has to offer.


I was at a kids party at Bubbles playhouse, and we had pizza. It was pretty good, nice thin crust but crunchy. I asked a staff member where it was from and they told me Brooklyn's Finest. I got a menu on my way home and will be ordering soon


Passed by Tuesday night on my way to prayer group and figured I'd grab a pie on my way home. I stopped in and much to my surprise they have a Tuesday $8 large pie special. Was completely unaware and the friendly staff told me the deal. Pizza was delicious can't wait tip next tuesday


Ordered from here Friday night and I was told 40 minutes for delivery it arrived within 30 minutes. I had the Mill Basin hero and it was delicious, next time we are coming in to eat! Good food good prices happy customer!


Brookylns finest what can I say it brings back memories of growing up in brooklyn the food is phenominal everyone must go and try brooklyns finest today


I've been searching for the right pizzeria on Staten Island for years now and I think I finally found a gold mine. Best pizzeria by far on this island with great service and delivery that comes in no longer then 40 mintutes. A great pizzeria!


I order here every Friday and the food and delivery never let's me down.looking forward to getting a nother calzone.


I moved away from Brooklyn 3 years ago and I have to say I was home sick from the Brooklyn style food. Once I heard about this restaurant I had to try it and let me tell you I thought I was back in Brookyln. Highly recommend this restaurant!!!


I order here every Friday and the food and delivery never let's me down.looking forward to getting a nother calzone.


this is my favorite pizzeria to go to when im realy hungry


I have been to brooklyns finest the last two Fridays The fresh fish steam table display felt like sheepshead bay on staten island not to mention the panelle special I grew up eating in carroll gardens. It's Brooklyn in our back yard


I heard about this place through a parent at my sons school and figure I'd give it a shot. Friday night I did just that and needless to say, I'm hooked. Growing up in park slope I enjoyed vanilla eggcreams panel sandwiches and riceball specials. After looking through the vast menu options I found all of these, and each were delicious and as close to my childhood memories as you can get. I will definitely be a returning customer.


I've been to brooklyn's finest four times since it's opened about a month ago. The food was great everytime i was there and i have tried many different things. Friendly atmosphere, very clean, it's a breathe of fresh air to have a place like this on staten island. I HIGHLY recommend it.


I thought the food was so so and will give them another try when I am in the area again. the place did appear to be clean which is a plus. Janet


this is the best pizza ive ever tasted its like eating a slice of heaven!


Quality food for a great price. Definatley will be returning here soon


Really great pizza and especially really great specials such as the Panelle Sandwich is only $4.99 and tastes really good. You can also have the Old Fashioned Brooklyn Egg Cream here for only 3 dollars. The pizza's are always fresh and they always have specialty slices available at all times which always taste fresh.


not to be confused with the pizzeria named brooklyn's finest as they are different owners and not related. the food here is typical run of the mill pizza. i think it could have been a little cleaner. but other then that not so bad.


Great pizza, friendly staff. Get the chicken vodka pie, out of this world


Much more than a pizza place, always have some sort of great meals and specials on display which are always tasty.


Really bad!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! SERVICE

User Photos from Brooklyn's Finest



1250 Hylan Blvd Staten Island, NY, 10305
Location : 718-865-8021

Today's Hours : 08:00AM to 10:30PM

(Now Closed)


Cuisine : Pizzeria, 


Services:
DeliveryCateringTake OutAlcohol/Beer/Wine
Price Range:

Features : Lunch Specials, Online Ordering, 


Type of Place : , 

Average Review Rating:


Message from Brooklyn's Finest

A large variety of tasty and authentic dishes.  Always fresh and always using only the top ingredients. Now Serving Beer!

Brooklyn's Finest accepts Online Ordering
For Delivery and Pick Up
Click here to Order Online

1250 Hylan Blvd
Staten Island, NY, 10305 Location :

Price Range

718-865-8021

Today's Hours : 08:00AM to 10:30PM

Cuisine : Pizzeria, 

Services :
DeliveryCateringTake OutAlcohol/Beer/Wine

Features : Lunch Specials, Online Ordering, 

Type of Place : , 

 77% Like it?

out of 141 votes

How about you ?

Average Review Rating :

Latest Reviews

Total Rating:
If you pay attention to review dates and volume compared to other places, you will see they are bogus. In addition, the bad reviews still show five stars. The pizza here is bad! The sandwiches are b
Kitchen prepared food is out on display making a quick stop for a home meal. Brooklyn's Finest is by far the best restaurant on this side of the island - and notice how I didn't say "piz

Some Dishes from Brooklyn's Finest

Staten Island Restaurants | Brooklyn Restaurants